More Animations vs. More Actor Types: The Zelda Dilemma
Gotchas
What are Animations?
Animations bring actors to life. They represent the visuals of an actor, its collision bounds and the notion of being in a certain "state" - such as running, walking and jumping.
What are examples of animation states?
A platformer hero's states (Stand, Walk, Run, Jump)
Treaure Chest (Opened, Not Opened)
Destructible Objects that "break" when hit by something else (Broken, Not Broken)
What does an Animation Consist of?
Each Animation state consists of 2 separate parts:
Frames (how it looks)
Collision Data (the collision shape )
Frames
Frames are like pages in a flipbook. Each frame represents a a different image or "page" in the book. When these images change quickly over a period of time, the result is an animation.
Every frame can be given a different duration (in milliseconds). Just double-click the box for it.
Notes: The minimum duration is 10ms. To edit multiple frame durations at a time, select multiple frames (using SHIFT or CTRL/Command) and click Edit Frame.
Looping
Frames can be set to loop or play once.
Origin Point
An Animation can also have a designated origin point. The origin point is used to determine the point by which an actor rotates or scales. By default, this is set to the center point.
Note: Origin Points are not implemented for mobile games. They will be supported for mobile games starting in Stencyl 2.5.
As their name suggests, Collision Bounds determine the physical shape(s) that an an actor assumes in a particular Animation state.
To define Collision Bounds, flip to the "Collisions" page of the Actor Editor. There, you will be able to edit your Animation's Collision Bounds on a per-animation basis.
Note: For your convenience, we default to a box that matches the size of the animation itself.
Tip: You cannot set collision bounds per-frame, yet. This can be worked around by defining a new animation per-frame and switching animations.
Now that you understand animations, let's go over the import process. You can import animations in one of several ways.
Pick an image.
Drag and Drop.
Method 1: Pick an Image
(Assuming you've got an Actor open in the Actor Editor...)
1) Click on "Click here to add frame" under the Frames pane.
2) You'll now see this dialog. Click the "Choose an Image..." button and pick out the desired image. Want to follow this exact example? Use this image.
3) Now, configure columns and rows to break up the image, as appropriate depending on how many cells it has in those directions.
4) If applicable, enter in values for the border and spacing fields. The majority of images do NOT need to worry about these fields.
5) Click Add. That's it!
After importing frames, you can give the Animation a name, alter frame durations and other properties we described above.
You can drag and drop an image into Stencyl while the Actor Editor is open. Doing this will bring up the dialog you see in method 1.
Notes
- Dragging in an animated GIF will bypass the dialog and immediately import the frames.
- Dragging in an image to the Dashboard or an editor that is not the Actor Editor will have varying effects, none which will import a new animation for the current Actor. Expected but worth noting.
Switching Animations
Notes
For all of these blocks, the "animation" blank takes in an Animation attribute or value. You can convert plain text into an Animation value using the "as animation" block.
All of these blocks are found under Actor > Drawing.
Switch Animation
Note: As stated right above, if you want to type in the name of the Animation directly, use the "as animation" block.
What's the current Animation?
Is the current Animation still playing?
Sometimes, it's useful to check if the current animation is still playing, particularly if the animation does not loop, and you want to detect if it has finished playing through.
Controlling Playback
Switch to Frame
This block lets you skip around or reset an animation to its starting frame.
Note: Frame indices are displayed in the gray boxes and start from 0. Switching to an invalid frame leads to nothing happening.
Current Frame Index
Total Frame Count
More Animations or More Actors?
There is no limit to the number of animations an actor may have. However, it's best to consider when it's appropriate to go with more animations or whether it's better to create a brand new actor.
The Zelda Dilemma
The Zelda Dilemma is a classic game design problem you run into when making an Adventure game and decide how you want to create your Hero character.
So suppose that we start with just the basic animations.
Walk
Left
Right
Up
Down
Not to bad so far. But Link holds a sword! So we have to add 2 more sets of animations, one for holding the sword and one for slashing it.
Walk
Left
Right
Up
Down
Walk + Sword
Left
Right
Up
Down
Walk + Slashing Sword
Left
Right
Up
Down
But wait, there's more! Link changes swords throughought the game. He can hold the plain sword, the Master Sword and the Golden Sword, and they all look different! That would triple the animation count.
And what about the Bow and Arrow, holding a shield and... you get the picture.
The Bottom Line
In cases like these, it's better to create a new actor rather than add more animations. This is particularly applicable when an actor equips items that slightly alter the appearance and could be accurately and convincingly drawn separately.
(From Zelda - the sword is a separate actor)
There are other benefits to having different actors.
Easier to define collision bounds, particularly for weapons.
Confine extra behaviors to the separate actor, rather than creating 1 monolithic actor with everything.
The bottom line is that there's no silver bullet and no simple rule. You simply have to create and recognize when things are going the wrong way. Hopefully this example shines light on a case where it's thoroughly clear that an all animations approach is flawed.
Gotchas
It's best if all animations are the same size.
It may be necessary in some cases to ensure that all animations of an actor are equal in size. Making animations different sizes, for the same actor, could have a negative impact, especially if the origin point is different in each animation.
Two common scenarios are:
The actor magically jumps to a slightly off-center location when you switch animations.
The actor's collisions mess up because the new animation has the collision bounds located in a different part of the animation.
Note: This gotcha has been a pain point for some. We're working on addressing this point for Stencyl 2.x.
Animations, Blocks & Attributes
Note that when using the "switch animation" block, you cannot type text directly into the blank. Instead, you have to wrap that text inside an "as animation" block like the following.
Reminder: All animation-related blocks are located under Actor > Draw.
Actors with No Animations
Actors with no animations at all may crash the game. We'll address this in a future version of Stencyl. Note that this is different from an Actor with a single blank (0 frame) animation, which will work just fine.
Summary
Animations are states, such as standing, walking and running.
Animations consist of frames (how it looks) and collision bounds.
Exercise good judgement in deciding whether to go with an actor with many animations versus several actors with fewer animations.
Challenge: Equipment for an Adventure Game
We talked about the "Zelda Dilemma" above. Now's your chance to see this for yourself and do things the right way.
Create a simple walkaround demo in which the character can equip different items that show up in that character. Do this the right way, by making those items each their own actors.
Last Updated: 2012-05-13 by Ceric
26768 have read this article
Disclaimer: The Stencyl Team does not actively monitor comments on articles. If you're seeking help for your game,
please ask a question on the forums. Thanks!
9 Comments
rainvillain This was a great tutorial but honestly this challenge is too much for me right now. Should I be worried? 03 months, 3 weeks ago
wilycodger Let's say your character has 3 items, and pressing "Space" cycles between them. How/where do you keep track of which item to create next? 04 months, 1 week ago
etfonehome Nevermind guys, there's a little plus button at the bottom in the column where it holds the states.
07 months, 2 days ago
etfonehome How do you add another state/animation? 07 months, 2 days ago
Lingesh7 love d description bt i was wondering wether to use vector/raster graphics (between adobe illustrator and adobe fireworks which is better for designing actors) 07 months, 4 weeks ago
BlueSideWind how do you make a "Slashing Animation" and trigger? 08 months, 1 week ago
SomeOnesBody It would be helpful to know where to find good sprites for the challenge... 010 months, 3 weeks ago
Blackalokalypse i think the concept of giving seperate components their own "actorship" would solve the problem with out having to make layers, as stated in the "breakdown" 01 year, 3 weeks ago
BossFight Is there a way to actually make a layered actor, like in the Zelda example? Or would we have to make (in the Zelda example) 12 x actors with their animations? 01 year, 1 month ago